How I might solve witching lands' unique statekeeping problem

the deck would often need to be kept divided in odd ways that would change frequently between sessions as a coven progressed through the game


One alternative to this would be a box with a ribbon attached to the bottom that you weave between the stacks as you put them in. Hmm... might actually be easier to manufacture, as it wouldn't require boring notches in the sides of the cards, it would only take a bit of glue

@faun Yeah, notching cards like that will require a custom die (adding to cost), I'd also be concerned about wear.

It is a clever thought, but I'm skeptical it would work well in practice; and unless that fastener is a ready made thing you are already familiar with, it would likely be exquisitely expensive to produce. (I have overseen the manufacturing of multiple commercial games, and had many things quoted.)

@faun The ribbon thing might be your best bet. You could also do cards that are slightly wider, but again would require a second, maybe custom, cutting die. And, if printed, would likely be disproportionately expensive because you only need a few of them. On the other hand, with a blank colored card stock, the cost could just be paper and labor, so maybe it could work out?

@grey <3 I hope we will be able to work together on getting this made if the game turns out to be good enough for production.

Right now I'm just going with makeplayingcards and I don't know if they have a card material option that prints without any alignment error, the cheapest two don't, it's Not Enough (but they're great for prototyping)

@faun Certainly happy to help how I can.

It's good to keep the practicalities in mind whenever you want to make something, but don't sweat the finishing details too much until you've decided things are "good enough" with the game's mechanics.

@grey I'd probably end up compromising on the fastener and just using some standard cord lock.

For wear.. hmm, the notches proposed there probably wouldn't do well, this sort of shape would probably have been better

Sign in to participate in the conversation

Merveilles is a community project aimed at the establishment of new ways of speaking, seeing and organizing information — A culture that seeks augmentation through the arts of engineering and design. A warm welcome to any like-minded people who feel these ideals resonate with them.